{ "alt": "Three rows of dots on one scale, one row each for the economic, moral and religious axes, with a dashed line at zero and a median mark in each row. Most dots in every row sit between zero and a small positive value, and the economic row has the longest right-hand tail, reaching its largest value in Sweden. Three further tabs list every country with its interval for one axis at a time.", "caption": "The three rows have similar medians, and the economic row has the longest right-hand tail. The other tabs list every country with its interval, largest loading first. The three axes rest on different numbers of items, so their sizes are not directly comparable.", "data": [], "id": "country_loadings", "notes": [ "Intervals treat the weighted sample as a simple random sample and ignore clustering and stratification in the sample design, which can raise or lower the variance." ], "source": "World Values Survey and European Values Study, fieldwork 2005-2023; weighted (weight, S017 within each country); countries with an effective sample of 300 or more", "spec": { "panels": [ { "figure": { "alt": "Three rows of dots on one scale, one row each for the economic, moral and religious axes, with a dashed line at zero and a median mark in each row. Most dots in every row sit between zero and a small positive value. The economic row has the longest right-hand tail, with Sweden the largest, followed by Iceland and New Zealand, and Mongolia the smallest.", "caption": "Each row is an axis and each dot is a country, colored by whether its 95% interval lies above zero, includes zero or lies below zero. The dashed line is zero.", "data": [ { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0591929, "conf_low": -0.0356932, "country": "Albania", "estimate": 0.0117764, "n": 2211, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.00573982, "conf_low": -0.163219, "country": "Algeria", "estimate": -0.079309, "n": 532, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.261056, "conf_low": 0.168836, "country": "Andorra", "estimate": 0.215426, "n": 1822, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.228116, "conf_low": 0.140209, "country": "Argentina", "estimate": 0.184532, "n": 2293, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0908789, "conf_low": 0.0169066, "country": "Armenia", "estimate": 0.0539667, "n": 3788, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.363231, "conf_low": 0.299496, "country": "Australia", "estimate": 0.331742, "n": 4426, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.25082, "conf_low": 0.172683, "country": "Austria", "estimate": 0.21209, "n": 2705, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": -0.00867512, "conf_low": -0.102087, "country": "Azerbaijan", "estimate": -0.0555027, "n": 2158, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0485264, "conf_low": -0.0646455, "country": "Bangladesh", "estimate": -0.00808542, "n": 1200, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0505568, "conf_low": -0.0196235, "country": "Belarus", "estimate": 0.0154857, "n": 3213, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.300056, "conf_low": 0.198136, "country": "Belgium", "estimate": 0.249788, "n": 1414, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0911545, "conf_low": -0.00163368, "country": "Bolivia", "estimate": 0.0448572, "n": 1778, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0185683, "conf_low": -0.0690444, "country": "Bosnia Herzegovina", "estimate": -0.0252866, "n": 2298, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.104036, "conf_low": 0.0386518, "country": "Brazil", "estimate": 0.0714209, "n": 3642, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.287214, "conf_low": 0.21049, "country": "Bulgaria", "estimate": 0.249243, "n": 2773, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0429698, "conf_low": -0.0775324, "country": "Burkina Faso", "estimate": -0.0173443, "n": 1058, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.318909, "conf_low": 0.259828, "country": "Canada", "estimate": 0.289645, "n": 5629, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "North America" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.307994, "conf_low": 0.205579, "country": "Chile", "estimate": 0.25751, "n": 2103, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0675593, "conf_low": 0.0122975, "country": "Colombia", "estimate": 0.039959, "n": 5016, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0661204, "conf_low": -0.0250433, "country": "Croatia", "estimate": 0.0205813, "n": 2352, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0364432, "conf_low": -0.0399848, "country": "Cyprus", "estimate": -0.00177341, "n": 3266, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.402446, "conf_low": 0.34539, "country": "Czechia", "estimate": 0.374272, "n": 3991, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.488275, "conf_low": 0.430464, "country": "Denmark", "estimate": 0.459857, "n": 4679, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0430947, "conf_low": -0.0397738, "country": "Ecuador", "estimate": 0.00166334, "n": 2238, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.22038, "conf_low": 0.147018, "country": "Egypt", "estimate": 0.183955, "n": 4238, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.293901, "conf_low": 0.228227, "country": "Estonia", "estimate": 0.261367, "n": 3302, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.276337, "conf_low": 0.191711, "country": "Ethiopia", "estimate": 0.234468, "n": 1917, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.46964, "conf_low": 0.404587, "country": "Finland", "estimate": 0.437686, "n": 2932, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.373014, "conf_low": 0.31205, "country": "France", "estimate": 0.342893, "n": 3827, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0669988, "conf_low": 0.00192617, "country": "Georgia", "estimate": 0.034499, "n": 4227, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.216677, "conf_low": 0.167691, "country": "Germany", "estimate": 0.192304, "n": 8683, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.296558, "conf_low": 0.211154, "country": "Ghana", "estimate": 0.254352, "n": 2333, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.235056, "conf_low": 0.15011, "country": "Greece", "estimate": 0.192944, "n": 2184, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0990158, "conf_low": -0.0133479, "country": "Guatemala", "estimate": 0.0429699, "n": 1213, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0175078, "conf_low": -0.0713435, "country": "Haiti", "estimate": -0.0269711, "n": 1944, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0184224, "conf_low": -0.0465154, "country": "Hong Kong SAR", "estimate": -0.0140613, "n": 3946, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0302837, "conf_low": -0.0389056, "country": "Hungary", "estimate": -0.00431613, "n": 3447, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.532499, "conf_low": 0.463036, "country": "Iceland", "estimate": 0.498567, "n": 2307, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0850635, "conf_low": 0.0310363, "country": "India", "estimate": 0.0580924, "n": 5436, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0726415, "conf_low": -0.00238155, "country": "Indonesia", "estimate": 0.0351795, "n": 4061, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0685445, "conf_low": -0.0570177, "country": "Iraq", "estimate": 0.00578617, "n": 975, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.146619, "conf_low": -0.0097651, "country": "Ireland", "estimate": 0.0688498, "n": 687, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.274552, "conf_low": 0.209807, "country": "Italy", "estimate": 0.24245, "n": 3509, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.135771, "conf_low": 0.0696963, "country": "Japan", "estimate": 0.102847, "n": 3446, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.149454, "conf_low": 0.0467724, "country": "Kazakhstan", "estimate": 0.0983751, "n": 1500, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": -0.038506, "conf_low": -0.152518, "country": "Kenya", "estimate": -0.0958263, "n": 1161, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.108894, "conf_low": -0.0467392, "country": "Kosovo", "estimate": 0.0312667, "n": 654, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.160277, "conf_low": 0.0589432, "country": "Kyrgyzstan", "estimate": 0.109896, "n": 1461, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.113732, "conf_low": 0.0246008, "country": "Latvia", "estimate": 0.0693045, "n": 2056, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0359773, "conf_low": -0.0996561, "country": "Lebanon", "estimate": -0.0319867, "n": 834, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0422368, "conf_low": -0.0591759, "country": "Libya", "estimate": -0.00849139, "n": 2447, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.147046, "conf_low": 0.0544419, "country": "Lithuania", "estimate": 0.100963, "n": 1871, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.220863, "conf_low": 0.100474, "country": "Luxembourg", "estimate": 0.161268, "n": 1257, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0497595, "conf_low": -0.0745189, "country": "Macau SAR", "estimate": -0.0124277, "n": 995, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.00667459, "conf_low": -0.0699396, "country": "Malaysia", "estimate": -0.0316791, "n": 2613, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0800577, "conf_low": -0.0424827, "country": "Maldives", "estimate": 0.0188583, "n": 1023, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0751007, "conf_low": -0.0406303, "country": "Mali", "estimate": 0.0172931, "n": 1147, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.330192, "conf_low": 0.186768, "country": "Malta", "estimate": 0.259913, "n": 750, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0449253, "conf_low": -0.0123008, "country": "Mexico", "estimate": 0.0163256, "n": 4752, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.149727, "conf_low": 0.053359, "country": "Moldova", "estimate": 0.101782, "n": 1651, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": -0.104473, "conf_low": -0.204918, "country": "Mongolia", "estimate": -0.155096, "n": 1613, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0171304, "conf_low": -0.101937, "country": "Montenegro", "estimate": -0.0425544, "n": 1250, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.138867, "conf_low": 0.0499408, "country": "Morocco", "estimate": 0.0945926, "n": 1909, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.413037, "conf_low": 0.373196, "country": "Netherlands", "estimate": 0.393301, "n": 7741, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.504063, "conf_low": 0.420907, "country": "New Zealand", "estimate": 0.463505, "n": 1372, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": -0.00129106, "conf_low": -0.13354, "country": "Nicaragua", "estimate": -0.0677128, "n": 871, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.044936, "conf_low": -0.0370888, "country": "Nigeria", "estimate": 0.00393021, "n": 2927, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0697476, "conf_low": -0.0299747, "country": "North Macedonia", "estimate": 0.019936, "n": 1759, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.375532, "conf_low": 0.221891, "country": "Northern Ireland", "estimate": 0.300661, "n": 760, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.476444, "conf_low": 0.418894, "country": "Norway", "estimate": 0.448133, "n": 3148, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.20437, "conf_low": 0.0903456, "country": "Pakistan", "estimate": 0.147849, "n": 1200, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0454961, "conf_low": -0.0998219, "country": "Palestine", "estimate": -0.0273072, "n": 727, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.101441, "conf_low": 0.0309319, "country": "Peru", "estimate": 0.0662694, "n": 3280, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0880793, "conf_low": 4.57515e-05, "country": "Philippines", "estimate": 0.0441482, "n": 2389, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0334789, "conf_low": -0.0337617, "country": "Poland", "estimate": -0.00014153, "n": 3718, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.17292, "conf_low": 0.0635191, "country": "Portugal", "estimate": 0.118579, "n": 1895, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.16672, "conf_low": 0.0469372, "country": "Puerto Rico", "estimate": 0.107217, "n": 1047, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.137846, "conf_low": 0.0777961, "country": "Romania", "estimate": 0.107919, "n": 4705, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0973932, "conf_low": 0.0306829, "country": "Russia", "estimate": 0.0641097, "n": 4564, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.145899, "conf_low": 0.069196, "country": "Rwanda", "estimate": 0.107708, "n": 2552, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0444329, "conf_low": -0.0313004, "country": "Serbia", "estimate": 0.00657569, "n": 3746, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.00303492, "conf_low": -0.0925538, "country": "Singapore", "estimate": -0.0448621, "n": 1743, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.162538, "conf_low": 0.0865832, "country": "Slovakia", "estimate": 0.124743, "n": 3336, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.00271162, "conf_low": -0.0682709, "country": "Slovenia", "estimate": -0.032821, "n": 3138, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0797789, "conf_low": 0.0123833, "country": "South Africa", "estimate": 0.0461336, "n": 5541, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0650501, "conf_low": -0.0164181, "country": "South Korea", "estimate": 0.0243564, "n": 3637, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.22523, "conf_low": 0.166221, "country": "Spain", "estimate": 0.195902, "n": 4200, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.612113, "conf_low": 0.569263, "country": "Sweden", "estimate": 0.591105, "n": 4213, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.368068, "conf_low": 0.318201, "country": "Switzerland", "estimate": 0.343376, "n": 5154, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": -0.055168, "conf_low": -0.129838, "country": "Taiwan ROC", "estimate": -0.0926334, "n": 3554, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Not classified" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.165395, "conf_low": 0.0535768, "country": "Tajikistan", "estimate": 0.109833, "n": 1200, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.069555, "conf_low": 0.00480537, "country": "Thailand", "estimate": 0.0372192, "n": 3758, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.103903, "conf_low": -0.0142826, "country": "Trinidad and Tobago", "estimate": 0.0449677, "n": 1211, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0192027, "conf_low": -0.0763113, "country": "Tunisia", "estimate": -0.0286196, "n": 1682, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.102856, "conf_low": 0.0526326, "country": "Turkey", "estimate": 0.0777936, "n": 6325, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.119452, "conf_low": 0.0325801, "country": "Ukraine", "estimate": 0.0761607, "n": 4667, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.390268, "conf_low": 0.337607, "country": "United Kingdom", "estimate": 0.364228, "n": 6124, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.437314, "conf_low": 0.384726, "country": "United States", "estimate": 0.411363, "n": 5866, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "North America" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.25218, "conf_low": 0.170539, "country": "Uruguay", "estimate": 0.211729, "n": 2571, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": -0.0487321, "conf_low": -0.207374, "country": "Uzbekistan", "estimate": -0.128878, "n": 591, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.297457, "conf_low": 0.190592, "country": "Venezuela", "estimate": 0.244768, "n": 1190, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.155448, "conf_low": 0.0508851, "country": "Vietnam", "estimate": 0.103452, "n": 1376, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.140321, "conf_low": 0.0137369, "country": "Zambia", "estimate": 0.0773407, "n": 948, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": -0.0355983, "conf_low": -0.125976, "country": "Zimbabwe", "estimate": -0.0809533, "n": 2627, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0648457, "conf_low": -0.0297743, "country": "Albania", "estimate": 0.017575, "n": 2220, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.00276597, "conf_low": -0.173233, "country": "Algeria", "estimate": -0.0886485, "n": 521, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.254033, "conf_low": 0.161491, "country": "Andorra", "estimate": 0.208228, "n": 1821, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.208227, "conf_low": 0.118664, "country": "Argentina", "estimate": 0.163783, "n": 2240, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0626315, "conf_low": -0.0115884, "country": "Armenia", "estimate": 0.0255568, "n": 3780, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.252082, "conf_low": 0.183959, "country": "Australia", "estimate": 0.218286, "n": 4430, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.225512, "conf_low": 0.146199, "country": "Austria", "estimate": 0.186159, "n": 2681, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0159613, "conf_low": -0.0781035, "country": "Azerbaijan", "estimate": -0.0311401, "n": 2138, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.222878, "conf_low": 0.112899, "country": "Bangladesh", "estimate": 0.168413, "n": 1200, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0222778, "conf_low": -0.0480308, "country": "Belarus", "estimate": -0.0128924, "n": 3202, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.132515, "conf_low": 0.0246079, "country": "Belgium", "estimate": 0.078792, "n": 1419, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0466864, "conf_low": -0.0462362, "country": "Bolivia", "estimate": 0.000225564, "n": 1780, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.168111, "conf_low": 0.0815529, "country": "Bosnia Herzegovina", "estimate": 0.12507, "n": 2285, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.122629, "conf_low": 0.0572785, "country": "Brazil", "estimate": 0.0900505, "n": 3624, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.0361745, "conf_low": -0.118868, "country": "Bulgaria", "estimate": -0.0776549, "n": 2709, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.0289233, "conf_low": -0.147081, "country": "Burkina Faso", "estimate": -0.0883129, "n": 1084, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.318222, "conf_low": 0.258962, "country": "Canada", "estimate": 0.288869, "n": 5604, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "North America" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.192201, "conf_low": 0.0837841, "country": "Chile", "estimate": 0.138407, "n": 2077, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.162985, "conf_low": 0.108651, "country": "Colombia", "estimate": 0.135921, "n": 5015, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.373842, "conf_low": 0.292975, "country": "Croatia", "estimate": 0.334023, "n": 2358, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.128177, "conf_low": 0.0523177, "country": "Cyprus", "estimate": 0.0903783, "n": 3262, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.0728047, "conf_low": -0.139081, "country": "Czechia", "estimate": -0.106061, "n": 3909, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.159871, "conf_low": 0.0878464, "country": "Denmark", "estimate": 0.124022, "n": 4701, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.000319747, "conf_low": -0.0824644, "country": "Ecuador", "estimate": -0.041143, "n": 2235, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.00587953, "conf_low": -0.0652284, "country": "Estonia", "estimate": -0.029712, "n": 3240, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.0646159, "conf_low": -0.153438, "country": "Ethiopia", "estimate": -0.109245, "n": 1902, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.1993, "conf_low": 0.12033, "country": "Finland", "estimate": 0.160071, "n": 2910, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.220021, "conf_low": 0.153248, "country": "France", "estimate": 0.18685, "n": 3818, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0948281, "conf_low": 0.0303027, "country": "Georgia", "estimate": 0.0626308, "n": 4271, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.184107, "conf_low": 0.134609, "country": "Germany", "estimate": 0.159458, "n": 8668, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.0393756, "conf_low": -0.130228, "country": "Ghana", "estimate": -0.0849786, "n": 2324, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.327243, "conf_low": 0.246369, "country": "Greece", "estimate": 0.287318, "n": 2188, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.117961, "conf_low": 0.00582263, "country": "Guatemala", "estimate": 0.0620877, "n": 1213, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0597316, "conf_low": -0.0294395, "country": "Haiti", "estimate": 0.0151762, "n": 1932, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.023179, "conf_low": -0.0878389, "country": "Hong Kong SAR", "estimate": -0.0555672, "n": 3955, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.124196, "conf_low": 0.0555693, "country": "Hungary", "estimate": 0.0899895, "n": 3448, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.199805, "conf_low": 0.109641, "country": "Iceland", "estimate": 0.155046, "n": 2306, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0299133, "conf_low": -0.0233477, "country": "India", "estimate": 0.00328512, "n": 5618, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0170518, "conf_low": -0.0577287, "country": "Indonesia", "estimate": -0.0203669, "n": 4086, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.193868, "conf_low": 0.0700512, "country": "Iraq", "estimate": 0.132476, "n": 968, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.295319, "conf_low": 0.143358, "country": "Ireland", "estimate": 0.220677, "n": 665, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.208402, "conf_low": 0.141142, "country": "Italy", "estimate": 0.174976, "n": 3452, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.173374, "conf_low": 0.107015, "country": "Japan", "estimate": 0.140352, "n": 3354, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0922751, "conf_low": -0.0112367, "country": "Kazakhstan", "estimate": 0.0406282, "n": 1500, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.160606, "conf_low": 0.0450566, "country": "Kenya", "estimate": 0.103179, "n": 1127, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0585147, "conf_low": -0.0971786, "country": "Kosovo", "estimate": -0.0194499, "n": 655, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.225401, "conf_low": 0.125937, "country": "Kyrgyzstan", "estimate": 0.176118, "n": 1459, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0649044, "conf_low": -0.0252513, "country": "Latvia", "estimate": 0.0198669, "n": 2028, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0693463, "conf_low": -0.0661813, "country": "Lebanon", "estimate": 0.0015898, "n": 837, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0438266, "conf_low": -0.0530037, "country": "Libya", "estimate": -0.00459934, "n": 2514, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.084868, "conf_low": -0.00964696, "country": "Lithuania", "estimate": 0.0376948, "n": 1829, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.291389, "conf_low": 0.174342, "country": "Luxembourg", "estimate": 0.233712, "n": 1254, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0804274, "conf_low": -0.0437032, "country": "Macau SAR", "estimate": 0.0184331, "n": 997, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.124936, "conf_low": 0.048825, "country": "Malaysia", "estimate": 0.0870076, "n": 2613, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.226015, "conf_low": 0.106839, "country": "Maldives", "estimate": 0.167037, "n": 1023, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0779563, "conf_low": -0.041252, "country": "Mali", "estimate": 0.0184176, "n": 1081, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.236358, "conf_low": 0.0866969, "country": "Malta", "estimate": 0.162462, "n": 751, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0843043, "conf_low": 0.0271313, "country": "Mexico", "estimate": 0.0557635, "n": 4734, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.02705, "conf_low": -0.0706582, "country": "Moldova", "estimate": -0.0218563, "n": 1638, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0614058, "conf_low": -0.0414977, "country": "Mongolia", "estimate": 0.00998046, "n": 1613, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.148291, "conf_low": 0.02999, "country": "Montenegro", "estimate": 0.0894559, "n": 1250, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0776668, "conf_low": -0.0120815, "country": "Morocco", "estimate": 0.0328589, "n": 1904, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.180487, "conf_low": 0.134689, "country": "Netherlands", "estimate": 0.157673, "n": 7801, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.240399, "conf_low": 0.137592, "country": "New Zealand", "estimate": 0.189515, "n": 1352, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.00908105, "conf_low": -0.123339, "country": "Nicaragua", "estimate": -0.0573811, "n": 871, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0450807, "conf_low": -0.0369277, "country": "Nigeria", "estimate": 0.00408336, "n": 2928, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.123992, "conf_low": 0.024869, "country": "North Macedonia", "estimate": 0.0746147, "n": 1763, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.330781, "conf_low": 0.171455, "country": "Northern Ireland", "estimate": 0.252832, "n": 749, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.156888, "conf_low": 0.0858872, "country": "Norway", "estimate": 0.121543, "n": 3142, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.206406, "conf_low": 0.0924529, "country": "Pakistan", "estimate": 0.149927, "n": 1200, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.159646, "conf_low": 0.015138, "country": "Palestine", "estimate": 0.0878544, "n": 725, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0240866, "conf_low": -0.0637132, "country": "Peru", "estimate": -0.0198516, "n": 2183, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0461795, "conf_low": -0.0420253, "country": "Philippines", "estimate": 0.00208112, "n": 2389, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.314999, "conf_low": 0.252565, "country": "Poland", "estimate": 0.284083, "n": 3646, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0986222, "conf_low": -0.0120692, "country": "Portugal", "estimate": 0.0434097, "n": 1915, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.168771, "conf_low": 0.049159, "country": "Puerto Rico", "estimate": 0.109361, "n": 1049, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.0286469, "conf_low": -0.0897653, "country": "Romania", "estimate": -0.0592616, "n": 4615, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0263978, "conf_low": -0.0409179, "country": "Russia", "estimate": -0.00726828, "n": 4507, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0338901, "conf_low": -0.0436801, "country": "Rwanda", "estimate": -0.00490239, "n": 2554, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.107193, "conf_low": 0.0307843, "country": "Serbia", "estimate": 0.0690898, "n": 3654, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.223771, "conf_low": 0.130845, "country": "Singapore", "estimate": 0.177704, "n": 1737, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.00148927, "conf_low": -0.0793901, "country": "Slovakia", "estimate": -0.0405012, "n": 3260, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.329628, "conf_low": 0.264713, "country": "Slovenia", "estimate": 0.297515, "n": 3127, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.0329304, "conf_low": -0.100366, "country": "South Africa", "estimate": -0.0667246, "n": 5512, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.240845, "conf_low": 0.162639, "country": "South Korea", "estimate": 0.202064, "n": 3637, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.350578, "conf_low": 0.295762, "country": "Spain", "estimate": 0.323441, "n": 4220, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0821699, "conf_low": 0.0159888, "country": "Sweden", "estimate": 0.0491333, "n": 4155, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.226959, "conf_low": 0.172744, "country": "Switzerland", "estimate": 0.200005, "n": 5159, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.154547, "conf_low": 0.0800569, "country": "Taiwan ROC", "estimate": 0.117467, "n": 3536, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Not classified" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0263935, "conf_low": -0.0866825, "country": "Tajikistan", "estimate": -0.0302413, "n": 1200, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.00558707, "conf_low": -0.0703968, "country": "Thailand", "estimate": -0.0380319, "n": 3751, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0439637, "conf_low": -0.0747018, "country": "Trinidad and Tobago", "estimate": -0.0154234, "n": 1206, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.132199, "conf_low": 0.0376908, "country": "Tunisia", "estimate": 0.0851363, "n": 1696, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.212242, "conf_low": 0.163861, "country": "Turkey", "estimate": 0.188166, "n": 6427, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0566757, "conf_low": -0.0321906, "country": "Ukraine", "estimate": 0.0122668, "n": 4550, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.198992, "conf_low": 0.139836, "country": "United Kingdom", "estimate": 0.169566, "n": 6116, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.397035, "conf_low": 0.342204, "country": "United States", "estimate": 0.369941, "n": 5823, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "North America" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.234732, "conf_low": 0.153106, "country": "Uruguay", "estimate": 0.194256, "n": 2600, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0729832, "conf_low": -0.0851339, "country": "Uzbekistan", "estimate": -0.00611358, "n": 615, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.079166, "conf_low": -0.0344309, "country": "Venezuela", "estimate": 0.02244, "n": 1190, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.179852, "conf_low": 0.0760849, "country": "Vietnam", "estimate": 0.12832, "n": 1381, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0951899, "conf_low": -0.032228, "country": "Zambia", "estimate": 0.0316094, "n": 945, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0216012, "conf_low": -0.0693414, "country": "Zimbabwe", "estimate": -0.0239196, "n": 2626, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.18012, "conf_low": 0.0867839, "country": "Albania", "estimate": 0.133748, "n": 2209, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0624678, "conf_low": -0.106832, "country": "Algeria", "estimate": -0.0223425, "n": 536, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.262432, "conf_low": 0.170015, "country": "Andorra", "estimate": 0.216709, "n": 1813, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.261566, "conf_low": 0.175644, "country": "Argentina", "estimate": 0.21903, "n": 2326, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0752884, "conf_low": 0.000882056, "country": "Armenia", "estimate": 0.0381381, "n": 3758, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.229768, "conf_low": 0.161156, "country": "Australia", "estimate": 0.195701, "n": 4456, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.168423, "conf_low": 0.088037, "country": "Austria", "estimate": 0.128441, "n": 2710, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0897673, "conf_low": -0.00391608, "country": "Azerbaijan", "estimate": 0.0430202, "n": 2152, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0622529, "conf_low": -0.0509227, "country": "Bangladesh", "estimate": 0.00568329, "n": 1200, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.106562, "conf_low": 0.0364328, "country": "Belarus", "estimate": 0.071586, "n": 3186, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.174288, "conf_low": 0.0673766, "country": "Belgium", "estimate": 0.121183, "n": 1421, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0983132, "conf_low": 0.00623816, "country": "Bolivia", "estimate": 0.052387, "n": 1803, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.234761, "conf_low": 0.149773, "country": "Bosnia Herzegovina", "estimate": 0.192628, "n": 2269, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.123942, "conf_low": 0.0590496, "country": "Brazil", "estimate": 0.0915928, "n": 3673, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0931483, "conf_low": 0.00946705, "country": "Bulgaria", "estimate": 0.0513979, "n": 2670, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0238179, "conf_low": -0.0937705, "country": "Burkina Faso", "estimate": -0.0350978, "n": 1109, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.28412, "conf_low": 0.223763, "country": "Canada", "estimate": 0.254189, "n": 5628, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "North America" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.146059, "conf_low": 0.0366866, "country": "Chile", "estimate": 0.0916491, "n": 2085, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.144256, "conf_low": 0.0896032, "country": "Colombia", "estimate": 0.117018, "n": 5005, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.399126, "conf_low": 0.319826, "country": "Croatia", "estimate": 0.360126, "n": 2354, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.112152, "conf_low": 0.0363199, "country": "Cyprus", "estimate": 0.0743435, "n": 3279, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0475435, "conf_low": -0.0198821, "country": "Czechia", "estimate": 0.0138465, "n": 3856, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.100269, "conf_low": 0.0272951, "country": "Denmark", "estimate": 0.0638676, "n": 4678, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0877319, "conf_low": 0.00513437, "country": "Ecuador", "estimate": 0.0465126, "n": 2243, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0392708, "conf_low": -0.0392081, "country": "Egypt", "estimate": 3.13898e-05, "n": 2721, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": -0.0250667, "conf_low": -0.0962403, "country": "Estonia", "estimate": -0.0607307, "n": 3216, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.157005, "conf_low": 0.0685366, "country": "Ethiopia", "estimate": 0.112995, "n": 1914, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.226736, "conf_low": 0.148351, "country": "Finland", "estimate": 0.187843, "n": 2897, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.217216, "conf_low": 0.150595, "country": "France", "estimate": 0.184117, "n": 3845, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.082735, "conf_low": 0.0181981, "country": "Georgia", "estimate": 0.0505193, "n": 4283, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.162995, "conf_low": 0.113075, "country": "Germany", "estimate": 0.138123, "n": 8654, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0727022, "conf_low": -0.0186005, "country": "Ghana", "estimate": 0.0271074, "n": 2330, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.329197, "conf_low": 0.247013, "country": "Greece", "estimate": 0.288637, "n": 2118, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.114475, "conf_low": 0.00219611, "country": "Guatemala", "estimate": 0.0585208, "n": 1211, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0542816, "conf_low": -0.034971, "country": "Haiti", "estimate": 0.00967458, "n": 1929, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0900627, "conf_low": 0.0240071, "country": "Hong Kong SAR", "estimate": 0.0570974, "n": 3801, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.186723, "conf_low": 0.118982, "country": "Hungary", "estimate": 0.153032, "n": 3432, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.174171, "conf_low": 0.0831518, "country": "Iceland", "estimate": 0.128933, "n": 2299, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.150403, "conf_low": 0.0987261, "country": "India", "estimate": 0.124649, "n": 5785, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.10309, "conf_low": 0.0285551, "country": "Indonesia", "estimate": 0.0659146, "n": 4082, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.13478, "conf_low": 0.0100669, "country": "Iraq", "estimate": 0.0727078, "n": 978, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.294656, "conf_low": 0.144625, "country": "Ireland", "estimate": 0.220947, "n": 682, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.225969, "conf_low": 0.159821, "country": "Italy", "estimate": 0.193114, "n": 3515, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.163446, "conf_low": 0.097222, "country": "Japan", "estimate": 0.130479, "n": 3386, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.159202, "conf_low": 0.0567312, "country": "Kazakhstan", "estimate": 0.108254, "n": 1500, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0197893, "conf_low": -0.0951614, "country": "Kenya", "estimate": -0.0378111, "n": 1160, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0225118, "conf_low": -0.133362, "country": "Kosovo", "estimate": -0.055765, "n": 650, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.233026, "conf_low": 0.133814, "country": "Kyrgyzstan", "estimate": 0.183888, "n": 1458, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0992355, "conf_low": 0.00942374, "country": "Latvia", "estimate": 0.0544397, "n": 2033, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.174326, "conf_low": 0.0401228, "country": "Lebanon", "estimate": 0.107715, "n": 834, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0792577, "conf_low": -0.0155199, "country": "Libya", "estimate": 0.0319407, "n": 2594, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.161972, "conf_low": 0.0681381, "country": "Lithuania", "estimate": 0.115312, "n": 1812, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.32739, "conf_low": 0.21305, "country": "Luxembourg", "estimate": 0.271176, "n": 1261, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.118739, "conf_low": -0.00509352, "country": "Macau SAR", "estimate": 0.057042, "n": 996, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.184158, "conf_low": 0.109118, "country": "Malaysia", "estimate": 0.146849, "n": 2613, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.152292, "conf_low": 0.0307382, "country": "Maldives", "estimate": 0.0918571, "n": 1023, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0716799, "conf_low": -0.044419, "country": "Mali", "estimate": 0.0136765, "n": 1140, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.145444, "conf_low": -0.00561426, "country": "Malta", "estimate": 0.0703178, "n": 770, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.126732, "conf_low": 0.0702185, "country": "Mexico", "estimate": 0.0985546, "n": 4781, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.096141, "conf_low": -0.000832241, "country": "Moldova", "estimate": 0.0477669, "n": 1657, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.25059, "conf_low": 0.15179, "country": "Mongolia", "estimate": 0.201703, "n": 1611, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.205177, "conf_low": 0.0867687, "country": "Montenegro", "estimate": 0.146497, "n": 1218, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0835444, "conf_low": -0.00593044, "country": "Morocco", "estimate": 0.0388849, "n": 1914, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.14846, "conf_low": 0.102168, "country": "Netherlands", "estimate": 0.125382, "n": 7785, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.18141, "conf_low": 0.0769158, "country": "New Zealand", "estimate": 0.129522, "n": 1361, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0843377, "conf_low": -0.0484745, "country": "Nicaragua", "estimate": 0.018011, "n": 871, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0846523, "conf_low": 0.002816, "country": "Nigeria", "estimate": 0.0438077, "n": 2929, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.137821, "conf_low": 0.0378193, "country": "North Macedonia", "estimate": 0.0880419, "n": 1729, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.242702, "conf_low": 0.0786977, "country": "Northern Ireland", "estimate": 0.161817, "n": 763, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.129039, "conf_low": 0.05763, "country": "Norway", "estimate": 0.0934545, "n": 3144, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.223478, "conf_low": 0.110169, "country": "Pakistan", "estimate": 0.167376, "n": 1200, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.160582, "conf_low": 0.0164002, "country": "Palestine", "estimate": 0.0889572, "n": 728, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.110319, "conf_low": 0.0405184, "country": "Peru", "estimate": 0.0755112, "n": 3339, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.116797, "conf_low": 0.0290429, "country": "Philippines", "estimate": 0.0730615, "n": 2388, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.310932, "conf_low": 0.248835, "country": "Poland", "estimate": 0.280176, "n": 3703, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.200654, "conf_low": 0.0928929, "country": "Portugal", "estimate": 0.14721, "n": 1954, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0884185, "conf_low": -0.0329484, "country": "Puerto Rico", "estimate": 0.0278376, "n": 1042, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0374424, "conf_low": -0.0231565, "country": "Romania", "estimate": 0.00714954, "n": 4728, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.141632, "conf_low": 0.0744333, "country": "Russia", "estimate": 0.108156, "n": 4411, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0360522, "conf_low": -0.0415193, "country": "Rwanda", "estimate": -0.00273766, "n": 2554, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.116907, "conf_low": 0.0411722, "country": "Serbia", "estimate": 0.0791536, "n": 3715, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.152857, "conf_low": 0.0580605, "country": "Singapore", "estimate": 0.105699, "n": 1740, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0255191, "conf_low": -0.0525024, "country": "Slovakia", "estimate": -0.0135122, "n": 3257, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.359466, "conf_low": 0.295605, "country": "Slovenia", "estimate": 0.32791, "n": 3098, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.108403, "conf_low": 0.041323, "country": "South Africa", "estimate": 0.0749478, "n": 5568, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0994001, "conf_low": 0.0181028, "country": "South Korea", "estimate": 0.058849, "n": 3631, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.386414, "conf_low": 0.333282, "country": "Spain", "estimate": 0.36014, "n": 4244, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0592083, "conf_low": -0.00703087, "country": "Sweden", "estimate": 0.0261174, "n": 4155, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.122083, "conf_low": 0.0659822, "country": "Switzerland", "estimate": 0.0941076, "n": 5138, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0535752, "conf_low": -0.0216312, "country": "Taiwan ROC", "estimate": 0.0159946, "n": 3561, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Not classified" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.323998, "conf_low": 0.219192, "country": "Tajikistan", "estimate": 0.272403, "n": 1200, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0486755, "conf_low": -0.0170684, "country": "Thailand", "estimate": 0.0158207, "n": 3656, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0825387, "conf_low": -0.0358751, "country": "Trinidad and Tobago", "estimate": 0.0234139, "n": 1210, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.159481, "conf_low": 0.0650687, "country": "Tunisia", "estimate": 0.112529, "n": 1681, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.237864, "conf_low": 0.190054, "country": "Turkey", "estimate": 0.214087, "n": 6438, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.14516, "conf_low": 0.0581651, "country": "Ukraine", "estimate": 0.101857, "n": 4601, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.151826, "conf_low": 0.0920524, "country": "United Kingdom", "estimate": 0.12205, "n": 6155, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.312507, "conf_low": 0.254273, "country": "United States", "estimate": 0.283651, "n": 5858, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "North America" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.241329, "conf_low": 0.159525, "country": "Uruguay", "estimate": 0.200777, "n": 2586, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.265358, "conf_low": 0.112926, "country": "Uzbekistan", "estimate": 0.190289, "n": 615, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0193832, "conf_low": -0.0941115, "country": "Venezuela", "estimate": -0.037485, "n": 1190, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.138647, "conf_low": 0.0336281, "country": "Vietnam", "estimate": 0.0863776, "n": 1373, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0425576, "conf_low": -0.0848625, "country": "Zambia", "estimate": -0.0212387, "n": 946, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.00326299, "conf_low": -0.0875473, "country": "Zimbabwe", "estimate": -0.0422294, "n": 2627, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" } ], "id": "country_loadings_strip", "spec": { "colors": { "Interval above zero": "accent", "Interval below zero": "highlight", "Interval includes zero": "muted" }, "group": "position", "highlight": [ "Sweden", "Iceland", "Mongolia", "Estonia", "Spain", "United States" ], "label": "country", "reference": 0, "row": "axis", "x": "estimate", "xDomain": [ -0.2, 0.7 ], "xLabel": "Loading: correlation of left-right with the axis" }, "subtitle": "One dot per country in each row; the vertical mark in each row is the median across countries", "table": { "columns": [ { "key": "country", "label": "Country" }, { "key": "axis", "label": "Axis" }, { "format": { "digits": 2, "signed": true }, "key": "estimate", "label": "Loading" }, { "format": { "digits": 2, "signed": true }, "key": "conf_low", "label": "Interval low" }, { "format": { "digits": 2, "signed": true }, "key": "conf_high", "label": "Interval high" }, { "key": "n", "label": "Respondents" }, { "key": "position", "label": "Interval relative to zero" }, { "key": "region", "label": "Region" } ] }, "title": "The economic loadings reach furthest to the right", "type": "beeswarm" }, "label": "All three axes" }, { "figure": { "alt": "A dot plot with one row per country and 95% intervals, sorted from the largest economic loading at the top to the smallest at the bottom, with a reference line at zero. Sweden is at the top, followed by Iceland, New Zealand, Denmark, Norway and Finland, and Mongolia is at the bottom.", "caption": "A dot to the right of the dashed line is a country where people who place themselves further right score higher on the economic index.", "data": [ { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0591929, "conf_low": -0.0356932, "country": "Albania", "estimate": 0.0117764, "n": 2211, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.00573982, "conf_low": -0.163219, "country": "Algeria", "estimate": -0.079309, "n": 532, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.261056, "conf_low": 0.168836, "country": "Andorra", "estimate": 0.215426, "n": 1822, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.228116, "conf_low": 0.140209, "country": "Argentina", "estimate": 0.184532, "n": 2293, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0908789, "conf_low": 0.0169066, "country": "Armenia", "estimate": 0.0539667, "n": 3788, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.363231, "conf_low": 0.299496, "country": "Australia", "estimate": 0.331742, "n": 4426, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.25082, "conf_low": 0.172683, "country": "Austria", "estimate": 0.21209, "n": 2705, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": -0.00867512, "conf_low": -0.102087, "country": "Azerbaijan", "estimate": -0.0555027, "n": 2158, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0485264, "conf_low": -0.0646455, "country": "Bangladesh", "estimate": -0.00808542, "n": 1200, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0505568, "conf_low": -0.0196235, "country": "Belarus", "estimate": 0.0154857, "n": 3213, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.300056, "conf_low": 0.198136, "country": "Belgium", "estimate": 0.249788, "n": 1414, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0911545, "conf_low": -0.00163368, "country": "Bolivia", "estimate": 0.0448572, "n": 1778, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0185683, "conf_low": -0.0690444, "country": "Bosnia Herzegovina", "estimate": -0.0252866, "n": 2298, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.104036, "conf_low": 0.0386518, "country": "Brazil", "estimate": 0.0714209, "n": 3642, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.287214, "conf_low": 0.21049, "country": "Bulgaria", "estimate": 0.249243, "n": 2773, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0429698, "conf_low": -0.0775324, "country": "Burkina Faso", "estimate": -0.0173443, "n": 1058, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.318909, "conf_low": 0.259828, "country": "Canada", "estimate": 0.289645, "n": 5629, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "North America" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.307994, "conf_low": 0.205579, "country": "Chile", "estimate": 0.25751, "n": 2103, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0675593, "conf_low": 0.0122975, "country": "Colombia", "estimate": 0.039959, "n": 5016, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0661204, "conf_low": -0.0250433, "country": "Croatia", "estimate": 0.0205813, "n": 2352, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0364432, "conf_low": -0.0399848, "country": "Cyprus", "estimate": -0.00177341, "n": 3266, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.402446, "conf_low": 0.34539, "country": "Czechia", "estimate": 0.374272, "n": 3991, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.488275, "conf_low": 0.430464, "country": "Denmark", "estimate": 0.459857, "n": 4679, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0430947, "conf_low": -0.0397738, "country": "Ecuador", "estimate": 0.00166334, "n": 2238, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.22038, "conf_low": 0.147018, "country": "Egypt", "estimate": 0.183955, "n": 4238, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.293901, "conf_low": 0.228227, "country": "Estonia", "estimate": 0.261367, "n": 3302, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.276337, "conf_low": 0.191711, "country": "Ethiopia", "estimate": 0.234468, "n": 1917, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.46964, "conf_low": 0.404587, "country": "Finland", "estimate": 0.437686, "n": 2932, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.373014, "conf_low": 0.31205, "country": "France", "estimate": 0.342893, "n": 3827, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0669988, "conf_low": 0.00192617, "country": "Georgia", "estimate": 0.034499, "n": 4227, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.216677, "conf_low": 0.167691, "country": "Germany", "estimate": 0.192304, "n": 8683, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.296558, "conf_low": 0.211154, "country": "Ghana", "estimate": 0.254352, "n": 2333, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.235056, "conf_low": 0.15011, "country": "Greece", "estimate": 0.192944, "n": 2184, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0990158, "conf_low": -0.0133479, "country": "Guatemala", "estimate": 0.0429699, "n": 1213, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0175078, "conf_low": -0.0713435, "country": "Haiti", "estimate": -0.0269711, "n": 1944, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0184224, "conf_low": -0.0465154, "country": "Hong Kong SAR", "estimate": -0.0140613, "n": 3946, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0302837, "conf_low": -0.0389056, "country": "Hungary", "estimate": -0.00431613, "n": 3447, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.532499, "conf_low": 0.463036, "country": "Iceland", "estimate": 0.498567, "n": 2307, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0850635, "conf_low": 0.0310363, "country": "India", "estimate": 0.0580924, "n": 5436, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0726415, "conf_low": -0.00238155, "country": "Indonesia", "estimate": 0.0351795, "n": 4061, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0685445, "conf_low": -0.0570177, "country": "Iraq", "estimate": 0.00578617, "n": 975, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.146619, "conf_low": -0.0097651, "country": "Ireland", "estimate": 0.0688498, "n": 687, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.274552, "conf_low": 0.209807, "country": "Italy", "estimate": 0.24245, "n": 3509, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.135771, "conf_low": 0.0696963, "country": "Japan", "estimate": 0.102847, "n": 3446, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.149454, "conf_low": 0.0467724, "country": "Kazakhstan", "estimate": 0.0983751, "n": 1500, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": -0.038506, "conf_low": -0.152518, "country": "Kenya", "estimate": -0.0958263, "n": 1161, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.108894, "conf_low": -0.0467392, "country": "Kosovo", "estimate": 0.0312667, "n": 654, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.160277, "conf_low": 0.0589432, "country": "Kyrgyzstan", "estimate": 0.109896, "n": 1461, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.113732, "conf_low": 0.0246008, "country": "Latvia", "estimate": 0.0693045, "n": 2056, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0359773, "conf_low": -0.0996561, "country": "Lebanon", "estimate": -0.0319867, "n": 834, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0422368, "conf_low": -0.0591759, "country": "Libya", "estimate": -0.00849139, "n": 2447, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.147046, "conf_low": 0.0544419, "country": "Lithuania", "estimate": 0.100963, "n": 1871, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.220863, "conf_low": 0.100474, "country": "Luxembourg", "estimate": 0.161268, "n": 1257, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0497595, "conf_low": -0.0745189, "country": "Macau SAR", "estimate": -0.0124277, "n": 995, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.00667459, "conf_low": -0.0699396, "country": "Malaysia", "estimate": -0.0316791, "n": 2613, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0800577, "conf_low": -0.0424827, "country": "Maldives", "estimate": 0.0188583, "n": 1023, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0751007, "conf_low": -0.0406303, "country": "Mali", "estimate": 0.0172931, "n": 1147, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.330192, "conf_low": 0.186768, "country": "Malta", "estimate": 0.259913, "n": 750, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0449253, "conf_low": -0.0123008, "country": "Mexico", "estimate": 0.0163256, "n": 4752, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.149727, "conf_low": 0.053359, "country": "Moldova", "estimate": 0.101782, "n": 1651, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": -0.104473, "conf_low": -0.204918, "country": "Mongolia", "estimate": -0.155096, "n": 1613, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0171304, "conf_low": -0.101937, "country": "Montenegro", "estimate": -0.0425544, "n": 1250, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.138867, "conf_low": 0.0499408, "country": "Morocco", "estimate": 0.0945926, "n": 1909, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.413037, "conf_low": 0.373196, "country": "Netherlands", "estimate": 0.393301, "n": 7741, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.504063, "conf_low": 0.420907, "country": "New Zealand", "estimate": 0.463505, "n": 1372, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": -0.00129106, "conf_low": -0.13354, "country": "Nicaragua", "estimate": -0.0677128, "n": 871, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.044936, "conf_low": -0.0370888, "country": "Nigeria", "estimate": 0.00393021, "n": 2927, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0697476, "conf_low": -0.0299747, "country": "North Macedonia", "estimate": 0.019936, "n": 1759, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.375532, "conf_low": 0.221891, "country": "Northern Ireland", "estimate": 0.300661, "n": 760, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.476444, "conf_low": 0.418894, "country": "Norway", "estimate": 0.448133, "n": 3148, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.20437, "conf_low": 0.0903456, "country": "Pakistan", "estimate": 0.147849, "n": 1200, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0454961, "conf_low": -0.0998219, "country": "Palestine", "estimate": -0.0273072, "n": 727, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.101441, "conf_low": 0.0309319, "country": "Peru", "estimate": 0.0662694, "n": 3280, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0880793, "conf_low": 4.57515e-05, "country": "Philippines", "estimate": 0.0441482, "n": 2389, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0334789, "conf_low": -0.0337617, "country": "Poland", "estimate": -0.00014153, "n": 3718, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.17292, "conf_low": 0.0635191, "country": "Portugal", "estimate": 0.118579, "n": 1895, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.16672, "conf_low": 0.0469372, "country": "Puerto Rico", "estimate": 0.107217, "n": 1047, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.137846, "conf_low": 0.0777961, "country": "Romania", "estimate": 0.107919, "n": 4705, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0973932, "conf_low": 0.0306829, "country": "Russia", "estimate": 0.0641097, "n": 4564, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.145899, "conf_low": 0.069196, "country": "Rwanda", "estimate": 0.107708, "n": 2552, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0444329, "conf_low": -0.0313004, "country": "Serbia", "estimate": 0.00657569, "n": 3746, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.00303492, "conf_low": -0.0925538, "country": "Singapore", "estimate": -0.0448621, "n": 1743, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.162538, "conf_low": 0.0865832, "country": "Slovakia", "estimate": 0.124743, "n": 3336, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.00271162, "conf_low": -0.0682709, "country": "Slovenia", "estimate": -0.032821, "n": 3138, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0797789, "conf_low": 0.0123833, "country": "South Africa", "estimate": 0.0461336, "n": 5541, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0650501, "conf_low": -0.0164181, "country": "South Korea", "estimate": 0.0243564, "n": 3637, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.22523, "conf_low": 0.166221, "country": "Spain", "estimate": 0.195902, "n": 4200, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.612113, "conf_low": 0.569263, "country": "Sweden", "estimate": 0.591105, "n": 4213, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.368068, "conf_low": 0.318201, "country": "Switzerland", "estimate": 0.343376, "n": 5154, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": -0.055168, "conf_low": -0.129838, "country": "Taiwan ROC", "estimate": -0.0926334, "n": 3554, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Not classified" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.165395, "conf_low": 0.0535768, "country": "Tajikistan", "estimate": 0.109833, "n": 1200, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.069555, "conf_low": 0.00480537, "country": "Thailand", "estimate": 0.0372192, "n": 3758, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.103903, "conf_low": -0.0142826, "country": "Trinidad and Tobago", "estimate": 0.0449677, "n": 1211, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.0192027, "conf_low": -0.0763113, "country": "Tunisia", "estimate": -0.0286196, "n": 1682, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.102856, "conf_low": 0.0526326, "country": "Turkey", "estimate": 0.0777936, "n": 6325, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.119452, "conf_low": 0.0325801, "country": "Ukraine", "estimate": 0.0761607, "n": 4667, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.390268, "conf_low": 0.337607, "country": "United Kingdom", "estimate": 0.364228, "n": 6124, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.437314, "conf_low": 0.384726, "country": "United States", "estimate": 0.411363, "n": 5866, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "North America" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.25218, "conf_low": 0.170539, "country": "Uruguay", "estimate": 0.211729, "n": 2571, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": -0.0487321, "conf_low": -0.207374, "country": "Uzbekistan", "estimate": -0.128878, "n": 591, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.297457, "conf_low": 0.190592, "country": "Venezuela", "estimate": 0.244768, "n": 1190, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.155448, "conf_low": 0.0508851, "country": "Vietnam", "estimate": 0.103452, "n": 1376, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": 0.140321, "conf_low": 0.0137369, "country": "Zambia", "estimate": 0.0773407, "n": 948, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Economic", "conf_high": -0.0355983, "conf_low": -0.125976, "country": "Zimbabwe", "estimate": -0.0809533, "n": 2627, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" } ], "id": "country_loadings_economic", "spec": { "colors": { "Interval above zero": "accent", "Interval below zero": "highlight", "Interval includes zero": "muted" }, "group": "position", "hi": "conf_high", "lo": "conf_low", "n": "n", "reference": 0, "sort": "desc", "x": "estimate", "xDomain": [ -0.2, 0.7 ], "xFormat": { "digits": 1, "signed": true }, "xLabel": "Loading: correlation of left-right with the axis", "y": "country" }, "subtitle": "Each dot is a country with its 95% interval, largest loading first", "table": { "columns": [ { "key": "country", "label": "Country" }, { "key": "axis", "label": "Axis" }, { "format": { "digits": 2, "signed": true }, "key": "estimate", "label": "Loading" }, { "format": { "digits": 2, "signed": true }, "key": "conf_low", "label": "Interval low" }, { "format": { "digits": 2, "signed": true }, "key": "conf_high", "label": "Interval high" }, { "key": "n", "label": "Respondents" }, { "key": "position", "label": "Interval relative to zero" }, { "key": "region", "label": "Region" } ] }, "title": "Sweden has the largest economic loading and Mongolia the smallest", "type": "dot" }, "label": "Economic" }, { "figure": { "alt": "A dot plot with one row per country and 95% intervals, sorted from the largest moral loading at the top to the smallest at the bottom, with a reference line at zero. The United States, Croatia and Spain are at the top and Ethiopia and Czechia are at the bottom.", "caption": "A dot to the right of the dashed line is a country where people who place themselves further right score higher on the moral index.", "data": [ { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0648457, "conf_low": -0.0297743, "country": "Albania", "estimate": 0.017575, "n": 2220, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.00276597, "conf_low": -0.173233, "country": "Algeria", "estimate": -0.0886485, "n": 521, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.254033, "conf_low": 0.161491, "country": "Andorra", "estimate": 0.208228, "n": 1821, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.208227, "conf_low": 0.118664, "country": "Argentina", "estimate": 0.163783, "n": 2240, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0626315, "conf_low": -0.0115884, "country": "Armenia", "estimate": 0.0255568, "n": 3780, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.252082, "conf_low": 0.183959, "country": "Australia", "estimate": 0.218286, "n": 4430, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.225512, "conf_low": 0.146199, "country": "Austria", "estimate": 0.186159, "n": 2681, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0159613, "conf_low": -0.0781035, "country": "Azerbaijan", "estimate": -0.0311401, "n": 2138, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.222878, "conf_low": 0.112899, "country": "Bangladesh", "estimate": 0.168413, "n": 1200, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0222778, "conf_low": -0.0480308, "country": "Belarus", "estimate": -0.0128924, "n": 3202, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.132515, "conf_low": 0.0246079, "country": "Belgium", "estimate": 0.078792, "n": 1419, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0466864, "conf_low": -0.0462362, "country": "Bolivia", "estimate": 0.000225564, "n": 1780, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.168111, "conf_low": 0.0815529, "country": "Bosnia Herzegovina", "estimate": 0.12507, "n": 2285, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.122629, "conf_low": 0.0572785, "country": "Brazil", "estimate": 0.0900505, "n": 3624, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.0361745, "conf_low": -0.118868, "country": "Bulgaria", "estimate": -0.0776549, "n": 2709, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.0289233, "conf_low": -0.147081, "country": "Burkina Faso", "estimate": -0.0883129, "n": 1084, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.318222, "conf_low": 0.258962, "country": "Canada", "estimate": 0.288869, "n": 5604, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "North America" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.192201, "conf_low": 0.0837841, "country": "Chile", "estimate": 0.138407, "n": 2077, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.162985, "conf_low": 0.108651, "country": "Colombia", "estimate": 0.135921, "n": 5015, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.373842, "conf_low": 0.292975, "country": "Croatia", "estimate": 0.334023, "n": 2358, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.128177, "conf_low": 0.0523177, "country": "Cyprus", "estimate": 0.0903783, "n": 3262, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.0728047, "conf_low": -0.139081, "country": "Czechia", "estimate": -0.106061, "n": 3909, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.159871, "conf_low": 0.0878464, "country": "Denmark", "estimate": 0.124022, "n": 4701, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.000319747, "conf_low": -0.0824644, "country": "Ecuador", "estimate": -0.041143, "n": 2235, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.00587953, "conf_low": -0.0652284, "country": "Estonia", "estimate": -0.029712, "n": 3240, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.0646159, "conf_low": -0.153438, "country": "Ethiopia", "estimate": -0.109245, "n": 1902, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.1993, "conf_low": 0.12033, "country": "Finland", "estimate": 0.160071, "n": 2910, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.220021, "conf_low": 0.153248, "country": "France", "estimate": 0.18685, "n": 3818, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0948281, "conf_low": 0.0303027, "country": "Georgia", "estimate": 0.0626308, "n": 4271, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.184107, "conf_low": 0.134609, "country": "Germany", "estimate": 0.159458, "n": 8668, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.0393756, "conf_low": -0.130228, "country": "Ghana", "estimate": -0.0849786, "n": 2324, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.327243, "conf_low": 0.246369, "country": "Greece", "estimate": 0.287318, "n": 2188, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.117961, "conf_low": 0.00582263, "country": "Guatemala", "estimate": 0.0620877, "n": 1213, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0597316, "conf_low": -0.0294395, "country": "Haiti", "estimate": 0.0151762, "n": 1932, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.023179, "conf_low": -0.0878389, "country": "Hong Kong SAR", "estimate": -0.0555672, "n": 3955, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.124196, "conf_low": 0.0555693, "country": "Hungary", "estimate": 0.0899895, "n": 3448, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.199805, "conf_low": 0.109641, "country": "Iceland", "estimate": 0.155046, "n": 2306, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0299133, "conf_low": -0.0233477, "country": "India", "estimate": 0.00328512, "n": 5618, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0170518, "conf_low": -0.0577287, "country": "Indonesia", "estimate": -0.0203669, "n": 4086, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.193868, "conf_low": 0.0700512, "country": "Iraq", "estimate": 0.132476, "n": 968, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.295319, "conf_low": 0.143358, "country": "Ireland", "estimate": 0.220677, "n": 665, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.208402, "conf_low": 0.141142, "country": "Italy", "estimate": 0.174976, "n": 3452, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.173374, "conf_low": 0.107015, "country": "Japan", "estimate": 0.140352, "n": 3354, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0922751, "conf_low": -0.0112367, "country": "Kazakhstan", "estimate": 0.0406282, "n": 1500, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.160606, "conf_low": 0.0450566, "country": "Kenya", "estimate": 0.103179, "n": 1127, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0585147, "conf_low": -0.0971786, "country": "Kosovo", "estimate": -0.0194499, "n": 655, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.225401, "conf_low": 0.125937, "country": "Kyrgyzstan", "estimate": 0.176118, "n": 1459, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0649044, "conf_low": -0.0252513, "country": "Latvia", "estimate": 0.0198669, "n": 2028, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0693463, "conf_low": -0.0661813, "country": "Lebanon", "estimate": 0.0015898, "n": 837, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0438266, "conf_low": -0.0530037, "country": "Libya", "estimate": -0.00459934, "n": 2514, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.084868, "conf_low": -0.00964696, "country": "Lithuania", "estimate": 0.0376948, "n": 1829, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.291389, "conf_low": 0.174342, "country": "Luxembourg", "estimate": 0.233712, "n": 1254, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0804274, "conf_low": -0.0437032, "country": "Macau SAR", "estimate": 0.0184331, "n": 997, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.124936, "conf_low": 0.048825, "country": "Malaysia", "estimate": 0.0870076, "n": 2613, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.226015, "conf_low": 0.106839, "country": "Maldives", "estimate": 0.167037, "n": 1023, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0779563, "conf_low": -0.041252, "country": "Mali", "estimate": 0.0184176, "n": 1081, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.236358, "conf_low": 0.0866969, "country": "Malta", "estimate": 0.162462, "n": 751, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0843043, "conf_low": 0.0271313, "country": "Mexico", "estimate": 0.0557635, "n": 4734, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.02705, "conf_low": -0.0706582, "country": "Moldova", "estimate": -0.0218563, "n": 1638, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0614058, "conf_low": -0.0414977, "country": "Mongolia", "estimate": 0.00998046, "n": 1613, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.148291, "conf_low": 0.02999, "country": "Montenegro", "estimate": 0.0894559, "n": 1250, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0776668, "conf_low": -0.0120815, "country": "Morocco", "estimate": 0.0328589, "n": 1904, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.180487, "conf_low": 0.134689, "country": "Netherlands", "estimate": 0.157673, "n": 7801, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.240399, "conf_low": 0.137592, "country": "New Zealand", "estimate": 0.189515, "n": 1352, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.00908105, "conf_low": -0.123339, "country": "Nicaragua", "estimate": -0.0573811, "n": 871, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0450807, "conf_low": -0.0369277, "country": "Nigeria", "estimate": 0.00408336, "n": 2928, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.123992, "conf_low": 0.024869, "country": "North Macedonia", "estimate": 0.0746147, "n": 1763, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.330781, "conf_low": 0.171455, "country": "Northern Ireland", "estimate": 0.252832, "n": 749, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.156888, "conf_low": 0.0858872, "country": "Norway", "estimate": 0.121543, "n": 3142, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.206406, "conf_low": 0.0924529, "country": "Pakistan", "estimate": 0.149927, "n": 1200, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.159646, "conf_low": 0.015138, "country": "Palestine", "estimate": 0.0878544, "n": 725, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0240866, "conf_low": -0.0637132, "country": "Peru", "estimate": -0.0198516, "n": 2183, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0461795, "conf_low": -0.0420253, "country": "Philippines", "estimate": 0.00208112, "n": 2389, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.314999, "conf_low": 0.252565, "country": "Poland", "estimate": 0.284083, "n": 3646, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0986222, "conf_low": -0.0120692, "country": "Portugal", "estimate": 0.0434097, "n": 1915, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.168771, "conf_low": 0.049159, "country": "Puerto Rico", "estimate": 0.109361, "n": 1049, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.0286469, "conf_low": -0.0897653, "country": "Romania", "estimate": -0.0592616, "n": 4615, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0263978, "conf_low": -0.0409179, "country": "Russia", "estimate": -0.00726828, "n": 4507, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0338901, "conf_low": -0.0436801, "country": "Rwanda", "estimate": -0.00490239, "n": 2554, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.107193, "conf_low": 0.0307843, "country": "Serbia", "estimate": 0.0690898, "n": 3654, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.223771, "conf_low": 0.130845, "country": "Singapore", "estimate": 0.177704, "n": 1737, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.00148927, "conf_low": -0.0793901, "country": "Slovakia", "estimate": -0.0405012, "n": 3260, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.329628, "conf_low": 0.264713, "country": "Slovenia", "estimate": 0.297515, "n": 3127, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.0329304, "conf_low": -0.100366, "country": "South Africa", "estimate": -0.0667246, "n": 5512, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.240845, "conf_low": 0.162639, "country": "South Korea", "estimate": 0.202064, "n": 3637, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.350578, "conf_low": 0.295762, "country": "Spain", "estimate": 0.323441, "n": 4220, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0821699, "conf_low": 0.0159888, "country": "Sweden", "estimate": 0.0491333, "n": 4155, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.226959, "conf_low": 0.172744, "country": "Switzerland", "estimate": 0.200005, "n": 5159, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.154547, "conf_low": 0.0800569, "country": "Taiwan ROC", "estimate": 0.117467, "n": 3536, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Not classified" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0263935, "conf_low": -0.0866825, "country": "Tajikistan", "estimate": -0.0302413, "n": 1200, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": -0.00558707, "conf_low": -0.0703968, "country": "Thailand", "estimate": -0.0380319, "n": 3751, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0439637, "conf_low": -0.0747018, "country": "Trinidad and Tobago", "estimate": -0.0154234, "n": 1206, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.132199, "conf_low": 0.0376908, "country": "Tunisia", "estimate": 0.0851363, "n": 1696, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.212242, "conf_low": 0.163861, "country": "Turkey", "estimate": 0.188166, "n": 6427, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0566757, "conf_low": -0.0321906, "country": "Ukraine", "estimate": 0.0122668, "n": 4550, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.198992, "conf_low": 0.139836, "country": "United Kingdom", "estimate": 0.169566, "n": 6116, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.397035, "conf_low": 0.342204, "country": "United States", "estimate": 0.369941, "n": 5823, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "North America" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.234732, "conf_low": 0.153106, "country": "Uruguay", "estimate": 0.194256, "n": 2600, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0729832, "conf_low": -0.0851339, "country": "Uzbekistan", "estimate": -0.00611358, "n": 615, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.079166, "conf_low": -0.0344309, "country": "Venezuela", "estimate": 0.02244, "n": 1190, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.179852, "conf_low": 0.0760849, "country": "Vietnam", "estimate": 0.12832, "n": 1381, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0951899, "conf_low": -0.032228, "country": "Zambia", "estimate": 0.0316094, "n": 945, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Moral", "conf_high": 0.0216012, "conf_low": -0.0693414, "country": "Zimbabwe", "estimate": -0.0239196, "n": 2626, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" } ], "id": "country_loadings_moral", "spec": { "colors": { "Interval above zero": "accent", "Interval below zero": "highlight", "Interval includes zero": "muted" }, "group": "position", "hi": "conf_high", "lo": "conf_low", "n": "n", "reference": 0, "sort": "desc", "x": "estimate", "xDomain": [ -0.2, 0.7 ], "xFormat": { "digits": 1, "signed": true }, "xLabel": "Loading: correlation of left-right with the axis", "y": "country" }, "subtitle": "Each dot is a country with its 95% interval, largest loading first", "table": { "columns": [ { "key": "country", "label": "Country" }, { "key": "axis", "label": "Axis" }, { "format": { "digits": 2, "signed": true }, "key": "estimate", "label": "Loading" }, { "format": { "digits": 2, "signed": true }, "key": "conf_low", "label": "Interval low" }, { "format": { "digits": 2, "signed": true }, "key": "conf_high", "label": "Interval high" }, { "key": "n", "label": "Respondents" }, { "key": "position", "label": "Interval relative to zero" }, { "key": "region", "label": "Region" } ] }, "title": "The moral loadings are largest in the United States, Croatia and Spain", "type": "dot" }, "label": "Moral" }, { "figure": { "alt": "A dot plot with one row per country and 95% intervals, sorted from the largest religious loading at the top to the smallest at the bottom, with a reference line at zero. Spain and Croatia are at the top and Estonia, at the bottom, is the only country with an interval below zero.", "caption": "A dot to the right of the dashed line is a country where people who place themselves further right score higher on the importance of God.", "data": [ { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.18012, "conf_low": 0.0867839, "country": "Albania", "estimate": 0.133748, "n": 2209, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0624678, "conf_low": -0.106832, "country": "Algeria", "estimate": -0.0223425, "n": 536, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.262432, "conf_low": 0.170015, "country": "Andorra", "estimate": 0.216709, "n": 1813, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.261566, "conf_low": 0.175644, "country": "Argentina", "estimate": 0.21903, "n": 2326, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0752884, "conf_low": 0.000882056, "country": "Armenia", "estimate": 0.0381381, "n": 3758, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.229768, "conf_low": 0.161156, "country": "Australia", "estimate": 0.195701, "n": 4456, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.168423, "conf_low": 0.088037, "country": "Austria", "estimate": 0.128441, "n": 2710, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0897673, "conf_low": -0.00391608, "country": "Azerbaijan", "estimate": 0.0430202, "n": 2152, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0622529, "conf_low": -0.0509227, "country": "Bangladesh", "estimate": 0.00568329, "n": 1200, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.106562, "conf_low": 0.0364328, "country": "Belarus", "estimate": 0.071586, "n": 3186, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.174288, "conf_low": 0.0673766, "country": "Belgium", "estimate": 0.121183, "n": 1421, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0983132, "conf_low": 0.00623816, "country": "Bolivia", "estimate": 0.052387, "n": 1803, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.234761, "conf_low": 0.149773, "country": "Bosnia Herzegovina", "estimate": 0.192628, "n": 2269, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.123942, "conf_low": 0.0590496, "country": "Brazil", "estimate": 0.0915928, "n": 3673, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0931483, "conf_low": 0.00946705, "country": "Bulgaria", "estimate": 0.0513979, "n": 2670, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0238179, "conf_low": -0.0937705, "country": "Burkina Faso", "estimate": -0.0350978, "n": 1109, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.28412, "conf_low": 0.223763, "country": "Canada", "estimate": 0.254189, "n": 5628, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "North America" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.146059, "conf_low": 0.0366866, "country": "Chile", "estimate": 0.0916491, "n": 2085, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.144256, "conf_low": 0.0896032, "country": "Colombia", "estimate": 0.117018, "n": 5005, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.399126, "conf_low": 0.319826, "country": "Croatia", "estimate": 0.360126, "n": 2354, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.112152, "conf_low": 0.0363199, "country": "Cyprus", "estimate": 0.0743435, "n": 3279, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0475435, "conf_low": -0.0198821, "country": "Czechia", "estimate": 0.0138465, "n": 3856, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.100269, "conf_low": 0.0272951, "country": "Denmark", "estimate": 0.0638676, "n": 4678, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0877319, "conf_low": 0.00513437, "country": "Ecuador", "estimate": 0.0465126, "n": 2243, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0392708, "conf_low": -0.0392081, "country": "Egypt", "estimate": 3.13898e-05, "n": 2721, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": -0.0250667, "conf_low": -0.0962403, "country": "Estonia", "estimate": -0.0607307, "n": 3216, "position": "Interval below zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.157005, "conf_low": 0.0685366, "country": "Ethiopia", "estimate": 0.112995, "n": 1914, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.226736, "conf_low": 0.148351, "country": "Finland", "estimate": 0.187843, "n": 2897, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.217216, "conf_low": 0.150595, "country": "France", "estimate": 0.184117, "n": 3845, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.082735, "conf_low": 0.0181981, "country": "Georgia", "estimate": 0.0505193, "n": 4283, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.162995, "conf_low": 0.113075, "country": "Germany", "estimate": 0.138123, "n": 8654, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0727022, "conf_low": -0.0186005, "country": "Ghana", "estimate": 0.0271074, "n": 2330, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.329197, "conf_low": 0.247013, "country": "Greece", "estimate": 0.288637, "n": 2118, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.114475, "conf_low": 0.00219611, "country": "Guatemala", "estimate": 0.0585208, "n": 1211, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0542816, "conf_low": -0.034971, "country": "Haiti", "estimate": 0.00967458, "n": 1929, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0900627, "conf_low": 0.0240071, "country": "Hong Kong SAR", "estimate": 0.0570974, "n": 3801, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.186723, "conf_low": 0.118982, "country": "Hungary", "estimate": 0.153032, "n": 3432, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.174171, "conf_low": 0.0831518, "country": "Iceland", "estimate": 0.128933, "n": 2299, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.150403, "conf_low": 0.0987261, "country": "India", "estimate": 0.124649, "n": 5785, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.10309, "conf_low": 0.0285551, "country": "Indonesia", "estimate": 0.0659146, "n": 4082, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.13478, "conf_low": 0.0100669, "country": "Iraq", "estimate": 0.0727078, "n": 978, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.294656, "conf_low": 0.144625, "country": "Ireland", "estimate": 0.220947, "n": 682, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.225969, "conf_low": 0.159821, "country": "Italy", "estimate": 0.193114, "n": 3515, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.163446, "conf_low": 0.097222, "country": "Japan", "estimate": 0.130479, "n": 3386, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.159202, "conf_low": 0.0567312, "country": "Kazakhstan", "estimate": 0.108254, "n": 1500, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0197893, "conf_low": -0.0951614, "country": "Kenya", "estimate": -0.0378111, "n": 1160, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0225118, "conf_low": -0.133362, "country": "Kosovo", "estimate": -0.055765, "n": 650, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.233026, "conf_low": 0.133814, "country": "Kyrgyzstan", "estimate": 0.183888, "n": 1458, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0992355, "conf_low": 0.00942374, "country": "Latvia", "estimate": 0.0544397, "n": 2033, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.174326, "conf_low": 0.0401228, "country": "Lebanon", "estimate": 0.107715, "n": 834, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0792577, "conf_low": -0.0155199, "country": "Libya", "estimate": 0.0319407, "n": 2594, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.161972, "conf_low": 0.0681381, "country": "Lithuania", "estimate": 0.115312, "n": 1812, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.32739, "conf_low": 0.21305, "country": "Luxembourg", "estimate": 0.271176, "n": 1261, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.118739, "conf_low": -0.00509352, "country": "Macau SAR", "estimate": 0.057042, "n": 996, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.184158, "conf_low": 0.109118, "country": "Malaysia", "estimate": 0.146849, "n": 2613, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.152292, "conf_low": 0.0307382, "country": "Maldives", "estimate": 0.0918571, "n": 1023, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0716799, "conf_low": -0.044419, "country": "Mali", "estimate": 0.0136765, "n": 1140, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.145444, "conf_low": -0.00561426, "country": "Malta", "estimate": 0.0703178, "n": 770, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.126732, "conf_low": 0.0702185, "country": "Mexico", "estimate": 0.0985546, "n": 4781, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.096141, "conf_low": -0.000832241, "country": "Moldova", "estimate": 0.0477669, "n": 1657, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.25059, "conf_low": 0.15179, "country": "Mongolia", "estimate": 0.201703, "n": 1611, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.205177, "conf_low": 0.0867687, "country": "Montenegro", "estimate": 0.146497, "n": 1218, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0835444, "conf_low": -0.00593044, "country": "Morocco", "estimate": 0.0388849, "n": 1914, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.14846, "conf_low": 0.102168, "country": "Netherlands", "estimate": 0.125382, "n": 7785, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.18141, "conf_low": 0.0769158, "country": "New Zealand", "estimate": 0.129522, "n": 1361, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0843377, "conf_low": -0.0484745, "country": "Nicaragua", "estimate": 0.018011, "n": 871, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0846523, "conf_low": 0.002816, "country": "Nigeria", "estimate": 0.0438077, "n": 2929, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.137821, "conf_low": 0.0378193, "country": "North Macedonia", "estimate": 0.0880419, "n": 1729, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.242702, "conf_low": 0.0786977, "country": "Northern Ireland", "estimate": 0.161817, "n": 763, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.129039, "conf_low": 0.05763, "country": "Norway", "estimate": 0.0934545, "n": 3144, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.223478, "conf_low": 0.110169, "country": "Pakistan", "estimate": 0.167376, "n": 1200, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "South Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.160582, "conf_low": 0.0164002, "country": "Palestine", "estimate": 0.0889572, "n": 728, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.110319, "conf_low": 0.0405184, "country": "Peru", "estimate": 0.0755112, "n": 3339, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.116797, "conf_low": 0.0290429, "country": "Philippines", "estimate": 0.0730615, "n": 2388, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.310932, "conf_low": 0.248835, "country": "Poland", "estimate": 0.280176, "n": 3703, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.200654, "conf_low": 0.0928929, "country": "Portugal", "estimate": 0.14721, "n": 1954, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0884185, "conf_low": -0.0329484, "country": "Puerto Rico", "estimate": 0.0278376, "n": 1042, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0374424, "conf_low": -0.0231565, "country": "Romania", "estimate": 0.00714954, "n": 4728, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.141632, "conf_low": 0.0744333, "country": "Russia", "estimate": 0.108156, "n": 4411, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0360522, "conf_low": -0.0415193, "country": "Rwanda", "estimate": -0.00273766, "n": 2554, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.116907, "conf_low": 0.0411722, "country": "Serbia", "estimate": 0.0791536, "n": 3715, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.152857, "conf_low": 0.0580605, "country": "Singapore", "estimate": 0.105699, "n": 1740, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0255191, "conf_low": -0.0525024, "country": "Slovakia", "estimate": -0.0135122, "n": 3257, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.359466, "conf_low": 0.295605, "country": "Slovenia", "estimate": 0.32791, "n": 3098, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.108403, "conf_low": 0.041323, "country": "South Africa", "estimate": 0.0749478, "n": 5568, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0994001, "conf_low": 0.0181028, "country": "South Korea", "estimate": 0.058849, "n": 3631, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.386414, "conf_low": 0.333282, "country": "Spain", "estimate": 0.36014, "n": 4244, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0592083, "conf_low": -0.00703087, "country": "Sweden", "estimate": 0.0261174, "n": 4155, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.122083, "conf_low": 0.0659822, "country": "Switzerland", "estimate": 0.0941076, "n": 5138, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0535752, "conf_low": -0.0216312, "country": "Taiwan ROC", "estimate": 0.0159946, "n": 3561, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Not classified" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.323998, "conf_low": 0.219192, "country": "Tajikistan", "estimate": 0.272403, "n": 1200, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0486755, "conf_low": -0.0170684, "country": "Thailand", "estimate": 0.0158207, "n": 3656, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0825387, "conf_low": -0.0358751, "country": "Trinidad and Tobago", "estimate": 0.0234139, "n": 1210, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.159481, "conf_low": 0.0650687, "country": "Tunisia", "estimate": 0.112529, "n": 1681, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Middle East & North Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.237864, "conf_low": 0.190054, "country": "Turkey", "estimate": 0.214087, "n": 6438, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.14516, "conf_low": 0.0581651, "country": "Ukraine", "estimate": 0.101857, "n": 4601, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.151826, "conf_low": 0.0920524, "country": "United Kingdom", "estimate": 0.12205, "n": 6155, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.312507, "conf_low": 0.254273, "country": "United States", "estimate": 0.283651, "n": 5858, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "North America" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.241329, "conf_low": 0.159525, "country": "Uruguay", "estimate": 0.200777, "n": 2586, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.265358, "conf_low": 0.112926, "country": "Uzbekistan", "estimate": 0.190289, "n": 615, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "Europe & Central Asia" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0193832, "conf_low": -0.0941115, "country": "Venezuela", "estimate": -0.037485, "n": 1190, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Latin America & Caribbean" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.138647, "conf_low": 0.0336281, "country": "Vietnam", "estimate": 0.0863776, "n": 1373, "position": "Interval above zero", "region": "East Asia & Pacific" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.0425576, "conf_low": -0.0848625, "country": "Zambia", "estimate": -0.0212387, "n": 946, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" }, { "axis": "Religious", "conf_high": 0.00326299, "conf_low": -0.0875473, "country": "Zimbabwe", "estimate": -0.0422294, "n": 2627, "position": "Interval includes zero", "region": "Sub-Saharan Africa" } ], "id": "country_loadings_religious", "spec": { "colors": { "Interval above zero": "accent", "Interval below zero": "highlight", "Interval includes zero": "muted" }, "group": "position", "hi": "conf_high", "lo": "conf_low", "n": "n", "reference": 0, "sort": "desc", "x": "estimate", "xDomain": [ -0.2, 0.7 ], "xFormat": { "digits": 1, "signed": true }, "xLabel": "Loading: correlation of left-right with the axis", "y": "country" }, "subtitle": "Each dot is a country with its 95% interval, largest loading first", "table": { "columns": [ { "key": "country", "label": "Country" }, { "key": "axis", "label": "Axis" }, { "format": { "digits": 2, "signed": true }, "key": "estimate", "label": "Loading" }, { "format": { "digits": 2, "signed": true }, "key": "conf_low", "label": "Interval low" }, { "format": { "digits": 2, "signed": true }, "key": "conf_high", "label": "Interval high" }, { "key": "n", "label": "Respondents" }, { "key": "position", "label": "Interval relative to zero" }, { "key": "region", "label": "Region" } ] }, "title": "The religious loadings are largest in Spain and Croatia", "type": "dot" }, "label": "Religious" } ] }, "subtitle": "Weighted correlation between left-right self-placement (1 to 10, 10 = right) and the axis, within country; 95% intervals; fieldwork 2005-2023", "title": "Most country loadings are small and positive, and the largest are economic", "type": "tabs", "width": "wide" }